Karuk Tribe and Fishing Groups Call on Schwarzenegger to
Limit Gold Mining To Save Struggling Fisheries: In Wake of
Fisheries Closures, Tribe, Fishermen, and Conservationists Urge
Governor to protect critical habitats from Suction Dredge Mining
by S. Craig Tucker, Ph.D. Klamath Campaign Coordinator, Karuk
Tribe of California
June 18, 2008. Sacramento, CA – A Native Tribe along with
commercial and recreational fishermen called on Governor
Schwarzenegger today to restrict the controversial gold mining
technique known as suction dredge mining. The groups’ call to
limit the recreational mining technique comes as California
faces the worst fisheries collapse in history.
“In April, the state and federal government took
unprecedented emergency actions to completely close California’s
coast to recreational and commercial salmon fishing, something
that is causing severe economic harm to businesses and
communities,” said Brian Stranko, CEO of California Trout. “This
is why it is inappropriate and unacceptable for state government
to allow recreational suction dredge mining operations to
continue to harm fish, particularly endangered species like coho
salmon.”
Suction dredges are powered by gas or diesel engines that are
mounted on floating pontoons in the river. Attached to the
engine is a powerful vacuum hose which the dredger uses to
suction up the gravel and sand (sediment) from the bottom of the
river. The stream bed passes through a sluice box where heavier
gold particles can settle into a series of riffles. The rest of
the gravel and potentially toxic sediment is simply dumped back
into the river. Depending on size, location and density of these
machines they can turn a clear running mountain stream or river
segment into a murky watercourse unfit for swimming.
“Dredging disturbs spawning gravels and kills salmon eggs
and immature lamprey that reside in the gravel for up to seven
years before maturing. In a system like the Klamath where salmon
can be stressed due to poor water quality, having a dredge
running in the middle of the stream affects the fishes ability
to reach their spawning grounds,” according to Toz Soto, lead
fisheries biologist for the Karuk Tribe.
Soto adds, “there is a lot of mercury settled on the bottom
of these rivers from gold smelting operations from the 1800’s.
Dredging reintroduces mercury to the stream creating a toxic
hazard for fish and people.”
Exposure to mercury can lead to mental retardation and birth
defects.
The groups are hoping that the Governor will agree to a
provision added by the Legislature to the 2008 Budget Bill that
would establish a temporary moratorium on suction dredge mining
in areas that represent the most important habitat for salmon
and trout while the Department of Fish and Game revises (DFG)
its regulations in compliance with a 2006 court order.
“The 2.2 million Californians that buy fishing licenses
every year expect the Governor to protect both our natural
resources as well as our rural economies,” said Stranko.
According to the American Sportfishing Association, licensed
anglers in California contribute $4.9 billion annually to the
state’s economy This includes 43,000 jobs amounting to $1.3
billion in wages and salaries annually. Commercial salmon
fishing contributes $255 million and 2,263 jobs to the
California economy.
By comparison, DFG only issues 3,000 permits for suction
dredging each year.
For the Karuk Tribe the threat is even greater. “Suction
dredge mining is nothing more than recreational genocide. The
first gold rush killed more than half our people in 10
years.This modern gold rush continues to kill our fish and our
culture,” says Leaf Hillman of the Karuk Tribe.
“While we cannot harvest enough salmon for our ceremonies
or to meet our families’ food needs, miners are allowed to rip
and tear our river bottoms to shreds. We need the Governor to
take a stand with Native People and the 2.2 million anglers in
California - not 3,000 recreational gold miners,” added
Hillman.
In coming weeks the Governor will have to consider the groups’
proposal to limit mining as part of the 2008 Budget Bill to
provide interim safeguards while DFG conducts a two-year effort
to overhaul statewide regulations covering in stream mining.